Arbitration clauses in Georgia accident insurance policies are generally not enforceable. Georgia law exempts insurance contracts from arbitration enforcement and specifically bars mandatory arbitration in uninsured motorist coverage.
The insurance-contract exemption
The Georgia Arbitration Code, at O.C.G.A. § 9-9-2, does not enforce arbitration provisions contained in contracts of insurance. As a result, an insurer generally cannot compel a policyholder to arbitrate a coverage dispute based on a pre-dispute clause in the policy, even though similar clauses are enforced in many other kinds of contracts.
The uninsured motorist rule
For uninsured motorist coverage, the protection is more specific. O.C.G.A. § 33-7-11 provides that a UM endorsement may not contain a provision requiring arbitration of a claim, and it may not restrict the insured from hiring counsel or filing suit. Only the establishment of legal liability may be required, leaving the courthouse open to the insured.
What remains available
Parties can still agree to arbitrate a dispute voluntarily after it arises, since the prohibition targets clauses imposed in advance. Separately, some Georgia counties operate court-annexed, non-binding arbitration programs for cases under a certain value, which is a procedural step within the court system rather than a policy term. The exemption reflects a longstanding policy in Georgia favoring access to the courts for insurance disputes over private arbitration imposed in advance.
A policyholder in Georgia therefore generally retains the right to take an insurance dispute to court, since the law withholds enforcement of the arbitration clauses written into a policy.