Appealing a criminal conviction in Georgia begins with a strict deadline: a notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days of the entry of the sentence. The notice goes to the trial court, not the appellate court, and missing the deadline generally forfeits the right to a direct appeal. From there, the case moves into transcript preparation and assembly of the trial record.
The appeal targets legal errors, not a retrial of the facts. An appellate court does not hear new evidence or reweigh the testimony a jury already considered; it reviews what happened at trial for mistakes serious enough to have affected the outcome. Appellate counsel reviews the record, identifies potential reversible errors, and lays them out in written briefs.
Two courts handle these appeals. Most criminal appeals go to the Georgia Court of Appeals, but cases involving a murder conviction or a constitutional challenge to a statute go directly to the Supreme Court of Georgia. The Supreme Court can also choose to review a Court of Appeals decision through a discretionary process.
The grounds that succeed tend to be specific. Improperly admitted evidence, incorrect jury instructions, and ineffective assistance of counsel are among the errors that can support reversal, while disagreement with the jury’s view of the evidence rarely does. Most convictions are affirmed, which makes the quality of the trial record and the precision of the legal argument decisive. An appeal is less a second chance to argue innocence than a focused claim that a particular legal mistake changed the result.